-
Type:
Bug
-
Status: Closed
-
Priority:
Major
-
Resolution: No Action
-
Affects Version/s: CTSPR01
-
Fix Version/s: None
-
Component/s: cts
-
Labels:
-
Resolution:
15. The Proposal does not simplify TEMIX as claimed. Most, if not all, of the claimed benefits of the Proposal, are provided by TEMIX. The Proposal’s messages are not simpler than TEMIX messages and are likely incompatible (the messages are not yet published). TEMIX, as it stands, is fully capable of providing transactive services in any market, although its documentation in EMIX and EI could be “cleaned up” in a new standalone TEMIX profile of these standards. Hence the Proposal only adds confusion to the detriment of Transactive Energy progress
CTS avoids the complexity of EMIX, providing a semantically identical (therefore mappable) and easier to integrate approach for modern systems including financial markets.
Transition all RESOLVED to APPLIED excepting ENERGYINTEROP-706 per Energy Interoperation TC Motion April 28, 2022.
Transition all APPLIED to CLOSED per Energy Interoperation TC Motion April 28, 2022.
Comments in line in ALL CAPS.
15. The Proposal does not simplify TEMIX as claimed. Most, if not all, of the claimed benefits of the Proposal, are provided by TEMIX.
CTS LIMITS THE COMPLEXITY OF EMIX, PROVIDING A SEMANTICALLY IDENTICAL BUT EASIER TO INTEGRATE APPROACH FOR MODERN SYSTEMS. CTS ALSO WORKS WELL WITH MODERN FINANCIAL MARKETS.
The Proposal’s messages are not simpler than TEMIX messages and are likely incompatible (the messages are not yet published).
UNCLEAR. THE TEMIX PROFILE MESSAGES AND CTS ARE PUBLISHED. PLEASE SUPPLY MESSAGES REFERENCED VIA COMMENTS LIST
TEMIX, as it stands, is fully capable of providing transactive services in any market, although its documentation in EMIX and EI could be “cleaned up” in a new standalone TEMIX profile of these standards. Hence the Proposal only adds confusion to the detriment of Transactive Energy progress
COMPLEXITY OF THE UNDERLYING EMIX TYPES AND SCHEMAS HAS BEEN A BARRIER TO ADOPTION OF THE EARLIER SPECIFICATIONS. AS OBSERVED ELSEWHERE (EITRANSACTION) THE DEFINITIONS MAKE EXPENSIVE NETWORK CAPABILITY ASSUMPTIONS.