• Type: Bug
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Priority: Minor
    • Committee Draft
    • Affects Version/s: Working Draft
    • None
    • Environment:

      These comments apply to StateOfInterop-v1.0-cd04-rev01.odt

    • Hide

      Consider along with resolution of any public comments before going to Committee Specification.

      Show
      Consider along with resolution of any public comments before going to Committee Specification.

      I like this document very much. I am including a series of defects in one issue for possible repair following the Public Review. I expect that these will be minor and not require an additional public review.

      1. Introduction, 2nd paragraph: my spell checker wants "implementers" in place of "implementors."

      1. Introduction, 2nd paragraph: last line, "conform to the" not "conform the"

      General: We are using ODF throughout and some of the names of Conformance Targets of ODF 1.2 do not completely line up, now that OpenDocument is being used instead of ODF. (I think it is fine to define ODF in the introduction and be done with it. After all, OASIS trade-marked both terms.)

      2.1 final paragraph "cheap and effective" might not be the correct expression. "inexpensive" maybe, but perhaps it is more about being widely available and effective?

      2.2 1st paragraph. think 'interoperability is "the ... ' (not "The ...)

      3.1 scenario step 1, Authoring" "expresses his intentions" not "express his intentions" (and bonus points for a smooth rewording that avoids gender).

      3.1 scenario step 4, Decoding: "user then uses their"?

            Assignee:
            Robert Weir (Inactive)
            Reporter:
            Dennis Hamilton (Inactive)
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            0 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated: