PR08-E8 bQoS-Spec-cd03.pdf, Rating-Specification.pdf, BSLA-spec-cd03.pdf

XMLWordPrintable

    • Type: Sub-task
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Priority: Critical
    • cd04
    • Affects Version/s: cd03
    • Component/s: PR01 Comments
    • None
    • Hide

      This applies to all of the specs with the "any" extensibility element.

      "any" should instead be a list of artifacts in all versions of the specifications. The elements of the list are name-value pairs, where the name is constrained. the value can be "any".

      All "official and approved' extensions have EERP starting the name, e.g. EERP_extension1. No other implementation may use that reserved prefix for names of extensions. [addresses conformance]

      As the specs evolve and elements are brought in, there will then be no name conflict.

      Show
      This applies to all of the specs with the "any" extensibility element. "any" should instead be a list of artifacts in all versions of the specifications. The elements of the list are name-value pairs, where the name is constrained. the value can be "any". All "official and approved' extensions have EERP starting the name, e.g. EERP_extension1. No other implementation may use that reserved prefix for names of extensions. [addresses conformance] As the specs evolve and elements are brought in, there will then be no name conflict.
    • Hide

      Changed BQoS schema for extension element from <bqos:Extension> to <bqos:BQoSExtension>.

      Change the bQoS spec @ http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/soa-eerp/download.php/39307/SOA-EERP-bQoS-Spec-cd04.pdf to the following:

      291 /bqos:BQoS/bqos:BQoSExtension
      292 BQoSExtension element is an optional element that keeps different (extensible) elements to be
      293 specified in the future.
      294 /bqos:BQoS/bqos:BQoSExtension/

      {any}
      295 This is an extensibility mechanism to allow different (extensible) elements to be specified in the
      296 future. Unrecognized elements MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored.


      Changed bRating schema for extension element from <rt:Extension> to <rt:BRatingExtension>.

      Change the bRating spec @ http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/soa-eerp/download.php/39321/SOA-EERP-bRating-Spec-cd04.pdf to the following:

      279 /rt:BRating/rt:BRatingExtension
      280 BRatingExtension element is an optional element that keeps different (extensible) elements to be
      281 specified in the future.
      282 /rt:BRating/rt:BRatingExtension/{any}

      283 This is an extensibility mechanism to allow different (extensible) elements to be specified in the
      284 future. Unrecognized elements MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored. This can be one or more
      285 elements of /rt:BRaing/rt:BRatingExtension/Performance/QualityAssertionEvaluation for third
      286 party Service Rating Entities to provide their evaluation for how well the provider fulfill the Quality
      287 Assertion(s) of this service.

      Changed bSLA schema for extension element from <sla:Extension> to <sla:BSLAExtension>.

      Change the bSLA spec @ http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/soa-eerp/download.php/39310/SOA-EERP-bSLA-Spec-cd04.pdf to the following:

      320 /sla:BSLA/sla:BSLAExtension
      SOA-EERP-bSLA-Spec-cd04 12 September 2010
      Copyright © OASIS® 2010. All Rights Reserved. Page 11 of 41
      BSLAExtension element is an optional element that keeps different (extensible) 321 elements to be
      322 specified in the future.
      323 /sla:BSLA/sla:BSLAExtension/

      {any}

      324 This is an extensibility mechanism to allow different (extensible) elements to be specified in the
      325 future. Unrecognized elements MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored.

      Show
      Changed BQoS schema for extension element from <bqos:Extension> to <bqos:BQoSExtension>. Change the bQoS spec @ http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/soa-eerp/download.php/39307/SOA-EERP-bQoS-Spec-cd04.pdf to the following: 291 /bqos:BQoS/bqos:BQoSExtension 292 BQoSExtension element is an optional element that keeps different (extensible) elements to be 293 specified in the future. 294 /bqos:BQoS/bqos:BQoSExtension/ {any} 295 This is an extensibility mechanism to allow different (extensible) elements to be specified in the 296 future. Unrecognized elements MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored. Changed bRating schema for extension element from <rt:Extension> to <rt:BRatingExtension>. Change the bRating spec @ http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/soa-eerp/download.php/39321/SOA-EERP-bRating-Spec-cd04.pdf to the following: 279 /rt:BRating/rt:BRatingExtension 280 BRatingExtension element is an optional element that keeps different (extensible) elements to be 281 specified in the future. 282 /rt:BRating/rt:BRatingExtension/{any} 283 This is an extensibility mechanism to allow different (extensible) elements to be specified in the 284 future. Unrecognized elements MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored. This can be one or more 285 elements of /rt:BRaing/rt:BRatingExtension/Performance/QualityAssertionEvaluation for third 286 party Service Rating Entities to provide their evaluation for how well the provider fulfill the Quality 287 Assertion(s) of this service. Changed bSLA schema for extension element from <sla:Extension> to <sla:BSLAExtension>. Change the bSLA spec @ http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/soa-eerp/download.php/39310/SOA-EERP-bSLA-Spec-cd04.pdf to the following: 320 /sla:BSLA/sla:BSLAExtension SOA-EERP-bSLA-Spec-cd04 12 September 2010 Copyright © OASIS® 2010. All Rights Reserved. Page 11 of 41 BSLAExtension element is an optional element that keeps different (extensible) 321 elements to be 322 specified in the future. 323 /sla:BSLA/sla:BSLAExtension/ {any} 324 This is an extensibility mechanism to allow different (extensible) elements to be specified in the 325 future. Unrecognized elements MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored.

      • Suggestion: Please consider adding the following addition to all
        items that read: "This is an extensibility mechanism to allow
        additional attributes, based on schemas, to be added to the abbrvX
        element in the future. _*Requesting new elements for future
        versions of the specification should be considered before
        developing possible dependencies upon attributes which may be
        deprecated in favor of such future elements.*_ Unrecognized
        attributes MAY cause a fault or be silently ignored."

      WTC: This comment has several aspects.

      (1) The management of new attributes in the extensibility mechanism has a request for specific text
      (2) The evolvability and management of the spec requires a mechanism ("requesting new elements..." needs management)
      (3) The conformance statements must say something about conforming behavior if an attribute that is not understood is receive (the commenter's suggestion is in the description above)
      (4) Note should be taken that an arbitrary "any" at the end of an object is a serious barrier to evolution; viz. W3C TAG notes over the past 5+ years.

            Assignee:
            Szu Chang (Inactive)
            Reporter:
            Paul Yang (Inactive)
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: