475 - statement that there are no direct interactions across the ESI does not seem to be enforced in EI.

    • Type: Improvement
    • Resolution: No Action
    • Priority: Major
    • wd34
    • Affects Version/s: wd33
    • Component/s: spec
    • None
    • Hide

      The concept of ESI is not defined in Energy Interoperation. There is therefore no enforcement; configurations may bridge ESIs, but (out of scope for Energy Interoperation) the cleanest way is to place an actor at the ESI that presents the VEN role to the outside and the VTN role (if needed) to the inside.

      Close no action required.

      It is acceptable to delete line 475 and add a footnote "The SGIP I2G and B2G Domain Expert Working Groups are working on a definition of the ESI; a similar concept with the same name can be found in OpenHAN."

      Similarly the text near 1237 may be updated at the editor's discretion. There are no actionable or conformance items in that introductory material.

      Show
      The concept of ESI is not defined in Energy Interoperation. There is therefore no enforcement; configurations may bridge ESIs, but (out of scope for Energy Interoperation) the cleanest way is to place an actor at the ESI that presents the VEN role to the outside and the VTN role (if needed) to the inside. Close no action required. It is acceptable to delete line 475 and add a footnote "The SGIP I2G and B2G Domain Expert Working Groups are working on a definition of the ESI; a similar concept with the same name can be found in OpenHAN." Similarly the text near 1237 may be updated at the editor's discretion. There are no actionable or conformance items in that introductory material.

      475 It would seem that the assumption of no direct interaction across the ESI is not enforced in EI as multiple Resources inside the ESI are exposed to the grid side of the ESI

      If the customer side of the interface is managed using the VEN/VTN approach wherein the ESI is a VEN that does not expose any VTNs inside the ESI VEN then we can still observe 475.

      1238 Do all VENs have an ESI? For example does an aggregator acting as a VEN to an ISO have an ESI?

            Assignee:
            Toby Considine (Inactive)
            Reporter:
            Edward Cazalet (Inactive)
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            0 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: