Improve consistency of Party / Counterparty in tables

XMLWordPrintable

    • Type: Improvement
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Priority: Minor
    • ctsWD14
    • Affects Version/s: PR03
    • Component/s: cts, schema
    • Environment:

      Pim van der Eijk

    • Hide

      Using the interaction diagrams in CS03, base for Public Review 3, the interaction diagram for

      • EiDelivery correctly shows Party-Party (a 3rd party auditor)
      • EiTransaction correctly shows Party-CounterParty (with a space in the RHS)
      • EiTender correctly shows Party-CounterParty (wth a space in the RHS)
      • EiQuote shows Party-CounterParty (with a space in the RHS. For consistency this should show Party-Party, as there is no counterparty relationship in a quote.

      Correct EiQuote Sequence Diagram to show Party-Party.

      The labels are correct (slightly different for e.g. delivery, i.e. Requestor-DeliveryActor) in CTS PR01.

      Show
      Using the interaction diagrams in CS03, base for Public Review 3, the interaction diagram for EiDelivery correctly shows Party-Party (a 3rd party auditor) EiTransaction correctly shows Party-CounterParty (with a space in the RHS) EiTender correctly shows Party-CounterParty (wth a space in the RHS) EiQuote shows Party-CounterParty (with a space in the RHS. For consistency this should show Party-Party, as there is no counterparty relationship in a quote. Correct EiQuote Sequence Diagram to show Party-Party. The labels are correct (slightly different for e.g. delivery, i.e. Requestor-DeliveryActor) in CTS PR01.

      In writing the document, I noticed that the summary tables often have the same role names ("Party", "Party") but the activity diagrams use different roles ("Party", "CounterParty"). It might be clearer to have distinct roles in the summary tables that match the values in the activity diagram. (Other standards, such as UBL, do this in a similar way). If messages can go in either direction, the table should have a two rows for the two situations.

      The activity diagram in 7.5.1.1 has "Party" in both swimlanes, this could be changed to "Party", "CounterParty" as in the other diagrams for consistency.

            Assignee:
            Toby Considine (Inactive)
            Reporter:
            Toby Considine (Inactive)
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: