Details

    • Proposal:
      Hide

      (1) URI is a common term widely used throughout network discussions and defined in this use in Energy Interoperation [EI]. No action.

      (2) There is indeed a confusion between Marketplace, Market facet, Marketplace Facet. Separate original Market Context from [EI] as not useful, separated muddy Market/Marketplace fact section into three Facets (in progress), for Marketplace Information, Market Information, Party Registration.

      In Table 2-1, language is wrong.

      Replace

      An Actor wherein one or more Markets are conducted

      With

      A Marketplace, identified in [EMIX] by a URI, is the set of Markets accessible to a Party. The Marketplace Information Facet supplies information common to all Markets in the Marketplace. The Facet also enumerates all Resources and Products available in the Marketplace, as well as an enumeration of the Market for each Product.

      Removed overloading of Market Context, leaving only

      In EMIX, the Market Context is a URI identifying a Marketplace.

      All other information about the Marketplace Information and Market Information is moved to the sections on those respective facets.

      Show
      (1) URI is a common term widely used throughout network discussions and defined in this use in Energy Interoperation [EI] . No action. (2) There is indeed a confusion between Marketplace, Market facet, Marketplace Facet. Separate original Market Context from [EI] as not useful, separated muddy Market/Marketplace fact section into three Facets (in progress), for Marketplace Information, Market Information, Party Registration. In Table 2-1, language is wrong. Replace An Actor wherein one or more Markets are conducted With A Marketplace, identified in [EMIX] by a URI, is the set of Markets accessible to a Party. The Marketplace Information Facet supplies information common to all Markets in the Marketplace. The Facet also enumerates all Resources and Products available in the Marketplace, as well as an enumeration of the Market for each Product. Removed overloading of Market Context, leaving only In EMIX, the Market Context is a URI identifying a Marketplace. All other information about the Marketplace Information and Market Information is moved to the sections on those respective facets.
    • Resolution:
      Hide

      (1) URI is a common term widely used throughout network discussions and defined in this use in Energy Interoperation [EI]. No action.

      (2) There is indeed a confusion between Marketplace and Market Facets; rewrite to clarify.

      Show
      (1) URI is a common term widely used throughout network discussions and defined in this use in Energy Interoperation [EI] . No action. (2) There is indeed a confusion between Marketplace and Market Facets; rewrite to clarify.

      Description

      There are 30 specific recommendations in the "Specific Recommendations" section of the submitted Hammerstrom paper. I have numbered them all for traceability as I recombine them into specific issues. The original white paper/submission can be read in the URI under "environment"

      8. Table 2-1: Row “Market Context”: Acronym “URI” has not been previously defined and should be spelled out on its first use, please. 

      9. Table 2-2: Facet “Marketplace” might be needed where multiple markets exist. 

      • The Market is an object from among Marketplaces and may have numerous attributes.  

      21. Section 6: This is finally made clear that the “Market Facet” refers to a defined query behavior or “interaction profile.” Why not use an informative, intuitive name like “Request Market Characteristics” instead of inventing all these “facets”? 

        Attachments

          Activity

            People

            • Assignee:
              WilliamCox William Cox
              Reporter:
              Toby.Considine Toby Considine
            • Watchers:
              2 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: