[OFFICE-3551] ODF 1.2 Part 1 20.77 dr3d:end-angle inconsistent with <dr3d:rotate> description - OASIS Technical Committees Issue Tracker

XML

Word

Printable

Type: Sub-task
Status: Applied
Priority: Major
Resolution: Fixed
Affects Version/s: ODF 1.2 CD 05
Fix Version/s: ODF 1.2 CD 06
Component/s: Graphics, Part 3 (Schema) [1.2: 1]
Labels:
None
Environment:

This issue applies to the text of OpenDocument-v1.2-part1-editor-revision-08.odt

Proposal:

Hide

Reconcile the description with that for <dr3d:rotate> and make simpler.

E.g., It might be better to state the dependence on edge-rounding in the <dr3d:rotate> description and keep dr3d:end-angle very simple and just about the rotation angle. The rest can be handled with a reference to <dr3d:rotate>.

Show
Reconcile the description with that for <dr3d:rotate> and make simpler. E.g., It might be better to state the dependence on edge-rounding in the <dr3d:rotate> description and keep dr3d:end-angle very simple and just about the rotation angle. The rest can be handled with a reference to <dr3d:rotate>.
Resolution:
Hide

In 10.77 dr3d:end-angle

Remove the sentence:
The visible sides are closed and take into account the value of the dr3d:back-scale and dr3d:edge-rounding attributes.

Adapt the note to read:
Note: The visible effect of values larger than 360 degrees only differs from that of 360 degrees when the dr3d:back-scale attribute ha a value different than 100%.
Show
In 10.77 dr3d:end-angle Remove the sentence: The visible sides are closed and take into account the value of the dr3d:back-scale and dr3d:edge-rounding attributes. Adapt the note to read: Note: The visible effect of values larger than 360 degrees only differs from that of 360 degrees when the dr3d:back-scale attribute ha a value different than 100%.

The text in 20.77 for the dr3d:end-angle graphic property is inconsistent with the current description of <draw:rotate>.

1. The result of the 360 degree rotation is completely closed only if the back face is the same size as the front face.

2. Whether faces are closed or not and they are the same size or not determines whether rotations greater than 360 degrees have visible effect.

These deficiencies also apply to the Errata 02 correction, so there is no more to reconcile on that account.

This issue is recorded for consideration at an appropriate time, whether ODF-Next or in a beyond CD06 Public Review Draft.