-
Type:
Bug
-
Status: Applied
-
Priority:
Major
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Affects Version/s: ODF 1.2
-
Fix Version/s: ODF 1.4
-
Component/s: Graphics, Part 3 (Schema) [1.2: 1]
-
Labels:None
-
Proposal:
-
Resolution:
In schema v1.2 in <define name="draw-enhanced-geometry-attlist"> the attribute <attribute name="svg:viewBox"> is optional. But the element draw:enhanced-geometry has a lot of attributes and child elements, which use coordinates or length without unit. To determine their values with unit, the values of svg:viewBox are mapped to the position and size of the shape.
In case the attribute svg:viewBox is missing, current implementations act different. This was discussed in thread https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/201303/msg00036.html. The thread has an example document attached.
There are several solutions imaginable:
(1) Define a default viewBox, for example svg.viewBox="0 0 21600 21600". This solution is used in AOO.
(2) Define, that the viewBox is calculated from maximal and minimal values actually used. Calligra seems to do something of this kind
(3) Add, that the attribute svg:viewBox may not be missing, if there exists any position or length value without unit in the attributes and child elements.
(4) Add, that for interoperability the attribute svg:viewBox should not be missing, and missing attribute svg:viewBox gives implementation dependent results.
| Field | Original Value | New Value |
|---|---|---|
| Affects Version/s | ODF 1.2 [ 10017 ] | |
| Status | New [ 10000 ] | Open [ 1 ] |
As per 17 Oct. 2016
Patrick: set to ODF 1.3, make viewbox 3 and 4
Patrick: decide between 3 and 4
| Component/s | Part 1 (Schema) [ 10157 ] |
| Fix Version/s | ODF 1.4 [ 16163 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | ODF 1.3 [ 10019 ] |
Using an attribute dependency listing from Francis Cave, I suggest the following as a starting point for discussion:
Amending the svg:viewBox entry as follows:
The svg:viewBox attribute specifies a rectangle in a local coordinate system of a shape. The syntax for using this attribute is the same as the [SVG] syntax. The value of the attribute are four numbers separated by white spaces, which define the left, top, width, and height of the rectangle. Such local coordinate system is used by the draw:points 19.206 and svg:d 19.530 attributes, as well as by the attributes of <draw:enhanced-geometry> 10.6.2 element and its child elements which specify coordinates.
The rectangle specified be the svg:viewBox attribute is mapped to the rectangle in the outer coordinate system, specified by the position and size attributes of the shape.
To:
The svg:viewBox attribute specifies a rectangle in a local coordinate system of a shape. The syntax for using this attribute is the same as the [SVG] syntax. The value of the attribute are four numbers separated by white spaces, which define the left, top, width, and height of the rectangle.
The rectangle specified be the svg:viewBox attribute is mapped to the rectangle in the outer coordinate system, specified by the position and size attributes of the shape.
The svg:viewBox attribute and its value shall be present in the following cases:
- draw:formula (on <draw:equation>), if the value contains any of the following identifiers: 'bottom', 'height', 'left', 'right', 'top', 'width', 'xstretch', 'ystretch'. The final two in this list are as a result of the dependency upon draw:path-stretchpoint-x and draw:path-stretchpoint-y.
- draw:handle-position (on <draw:handle>), if the value contains any of the following handle position constants: 'bottom', 'height', 'left', 'right', 'top', 'width', 'xstretch', 'ystretch'.
- draw:path-stretchpoint-x (on <draw:enhanced-geometry>).
- draw:path-stretchpoint-y (on <draw:enhanced-geometry>).
- draw:points (on <draw:area-polygon>, <draw:contour-polygon>, <draw:polygon> and <draw:polyline>).
From the TC meeting on March 23, 2020:
The svg:viewBox attribute specifies a rectangle in a local coordinate system of a shape. The syntax for using this attribute is the same as the [SVG] syntax. The value of the attribute are four numbers separated by white spaces, which define the left, top, width, and height of the rectangle. Such local coordinate system is used by the draw:points 19.206 and svg:d 19.530 attributes, as well as by the attributes of <draw:enhanced-geometry> 10.6.2 element and its child elements which specify coordinates. The svg:viewBox attribute and its value shall be present in case of the draw:points and svg:d attributes. The svg:viewBox attribute and its value shall be present in case of <draw:enhanced-geometry>, if there exists any position or length value without unit in its attributes or child elements.
The rectangle specified by the svg:viewBox attribute is mapped to the rectangle in the outer coordinate system, specified by the position and size attributes of the shape.
As per TC - 23rd March 2020.
| Resolution | Fixed [ 1 ] | |
| Status | Open [ 1 ] | Resolved [ 5 ] |
| Resolution |
h2. 19.576 svg:viewBox
The svg:viewBox attribute specifies a rectangle in a local coordinate system of a shape. The syntax for using this attribute is the same as the [SVG] syntax. The value of the attribute are four numbers separated by white spaces, which define the left, top, width, and height of the rectangle. Such local coordinate system is used by the {{draw:points}} 19.206 and {{svg:d}} 19.532 attributes, as well as by the attributes of {{<draw:enhanced-geometry>}} 10.6.2 element and its child elements which specify coordinates. The {{svg:viewBox}} attribute and its value shall be present in case of the {{draw:points}} 19.206 and {{svg:d}} 19.532 attributes. The {{svg:viewBox}} attribute and its value shall be present in case of {{<draw:enhanced-geometry>}} 10.6.2, if there exists any position or length value without unit in its attributes or child elements. The rectangle specified be the {{svg:viewBox}} attribute is mapped to the rectangle in the outer coordinate system, specified by the position and size attributes of the shape. |
| Status | Resolved [ 5 ] | Applied [ 10002 ] |
Reviewed on 2013-04-15.
Possibly make viewBox non-optimal in ODF 1.3.