Uploaded image for project: 'OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC'
  1. OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC
  2. OFFICE-3873

PAS Comment JP2: Semantics of the interactions of the change-tracking elements are unclear

    Details

    • Proposal:
      Hide

      Resolution: https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/office/201809/msg00006.html

      "The under-specification of change tracking in ODF 1.2 resulted in a number of different choices being possible as to how to implement the feature. While each of these choices would be consistent with the way that the feature is specified, unless identical choices are made, it is likely that the resulting implementations would not be fully interoperable. For this reason, where interoperability of change tracking between implementations is required, implementers are recommended to carry out specific checks that their implementation choices are the same or similar enough to be interoperable."

      Show
      Resolution: https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/office/201809/msg00006.html "The under-specification of change tracking in ODF 1.2 resulted in a number of different choices being possible as to how to implement the feature. While each of these choices would be consistent with the way that the feature is specified, unless identical choices are made, it is likely that the resulting implementations would not be fully interoperable. For this reason, where interoperability of change tracking between implementations is required, implementers are recommended to carry out specific checks that their implementation choices are the same or similar enough to be interoperable."
    • Resolution:
      Hide

      The under-specification of change tracking in ODF 1.2 resulted
      in varying implementations of this feature. Where interoperability
      between implementations is required, this feature should be checked for
      interoperability.

      Show
      The under-specification of change tracking in ODF 1.2 resulted in varying implementations of this feature. Where interoperability between implementations is required, this feature should be checked for interoperability.

      Description

      Comment logged by national body during the ODF 1.2 PAS process, to be address at Ballot Resolution Meeting.

      Original text of NB comment: Semantics of the interactions of the change-tracking elements are unclear

      Proposed solution: Introduce a new sublause "5.5.0 General":

      5.5.0
      Semantics of the interactions of the elements defined in 5.5 are
      implementation-dependent.

        Attachments

          Activity

          Hide
          owittmann Oliver-Rainer Wittmann (Inactive) added a comment -

          on TC call 2014-12-22:
          agreed on the given resolution.

          Show
          owittmann Oliver-Rainer Wittmann (Inactive) added a comment - on TC call 2014-12-22: agreed on the given resolution.
          Hide
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment -

          Applied in new draft 17 April 2018.

          Show
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment - Applied in new draft 17 April 2018.
          Hide
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment -

          On 10 Sept. 2018, the following language was agreed to replace the proposal previously applied:

          "The under-specification of change tracking in ODF 1.2 resulted in varying implementations of this feature. Where interoperability between implementations is required, this feature should be checked for interoperability."

          Show
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment - On 10 Sept. 2018, the following language was agreed to replace the proposal previously applied: "The under-specification of change tracking in ODF 1.2 resulted in varying implementations of this feature. Where interoperability between implementations is required, this feature should be checked for interoperability."
          Hide
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment -

          Applied the new language to OpenDocument-v1.3-wd10-part3-documents.odt

          Show
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment - Applied the new language to OpenDocument-v1.3-wd10-part3-documents.odt
          Hide
          svante.schubert#1#1 svante.schubert#1#1 added a comment -

          Patrick realized during his work on visualizing the changes from ODF 1.2 to ODF 1.3 that in the schema part this issue still (or again) appears. We agreed on our last TC meeting: https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/office/202010/msg00007.html

          To fix this regression on our way to release ODF 1.3 CS02.

          Show
          svante.schubert#1#1 svante.schubert#1#1 added a comment - Patrick realized during his work on visualizing the changes from ODF 1.2 to ODF 1.3 that in the schema part this issue still (or again) appears. We agreed on our last TC meeting: https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/office/202010/msg00007.html To fix this regression on our way to release ODF 1.3 CS02.

            People

            • Assignee:
              svante.schubert#1#1 svante.schubert#1#1
              Reporter:
              chris.rae Chris Rae (Inactive)
            • Watchers:
              4 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: