Details

    • Proposal:
      Hide

      20.226 presentation:display-date-time
      The presentation:display-date-time attribute specifies the visibility of a drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element, where the shape has the presentation class date-time.
      The defined values for the presentation:display-date-time attribute are:

      • false: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class date-time should not be visible.
      • true: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class date-time should be visible.

      20.229 presentation:display-page-number
      The presentation:display-page-number attribute specifies the visibility of a drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element, where the shape has the presentation class page-number.
      The defined values for the presentation:display-page-number attribute are:

      • false: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class page-number should not be visible.
      • true: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class page-number should be visible.
      Show
      20.226 presentation:display-date-time The presentation:display-date-time attribute specifies the visibility of a drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element, where the shape has the presentation class date-time. The defined values for the presentation:display-date-time attribute are: false: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class date-time should not be visible. true: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class date-time should be visible. 20.229 presentation:display-page-number The presentation:display-page-number attribute specifies the visibility of a drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element, where the shape has the presentation class page-number. The defined values for the presentation:display-page-number attribute are: false: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class page-number should not be visible. true: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class page-number should be visible.

      Description

      As described in issue 3930, the first sentence needs to be corrected.

      But in addition I have noticed this:
      In date-time case the wording is
      "false: drawing shape from a <style:master-page> element with the presentation class date-time should not be visible."
      whereas for footer, header and page-number cases it is
      "false: drawing shape used as a *** of a <style:master-page> element should not be visible.

      That is inconsistent.

      ODF 1.1 is more explicit about the condition by referring to the presentation:class attribute (now 19.389). In ODF 1.1 you read e.g.
      "The presentation:display-date-time attribute sets the visibility of presentation shapes from the master page with the presentation class date-time."

      Any reason for mentioning presentation:class in case date-time and not in the other cases?

      Should we remove the inconsistency in addition to correcting the broken sentence?

      If yes, remove reference to presentation:class from date-time case, or add reference to presentation:class for the other cases?

        Attachments

          Activity

          Hide
          regina.henschel Regina Henschel added a comment -

          After a deeper look I have updated the proposal. Here the reasoning:

          20.226 presentation:display-date-time
          Display of a date or time by means of a master-page is possible with the element

          <draw:frame presentation:class="date-time">
          <draw:text-box>
          <text>
          <presentation:date-time />
          </text>
          </draw:text-box>
          </draw:frame>

          But it is also possible with the element

          <draw:frame >
          <draw:text-box>
          <text>
          <text:date>...</text:date>
          </text>
          </draw:text-box>
          </draw:frame>

          The attribute presentation:display-date-time only affects the element with presentation:class="date-time". Therefore the current wording with mentioning the presentation class is preferable to the wording, which is used for header or footer.

          20.229 presentation:display-page-number
          The following two structures are possible within a <style:master-page> element to get a page number.

          <draw:frame presentation:class="page-number">
          <draw:text-box>
          <text>
          <text:page-number><number></text:page-number>
          </text>
          </draw:text-box>
          </draw:frame>

          <draw:frame>
          <draw:text-box>
          <text>
          <text:page-number><number></text:page-number>
          </text>
          </draw:text-box>
          </draw:frame>

          The only difference is, whether the presentation:class attribute is present or not. The presentation:display-page-number attribute affects only the <draw:frame> element with attribute presentation:class="page-number."

          Because both <draw:frame> elements meet the current wording "drawing shape used as a page number" a clarification is needed.

          20.227 presentation:footer
          20.228 presentation:header
          For footer or header no similar conflict exists. Therefore the wording needs no change.

          Show
          regina.henschel Regina Henschel added a comment - After a deeper look I have updated the proposal. Here the reasoning: 20.226 presentation:display-date-time Display of a date or time by means of a master-page is possible with the element <draw:frame presentation:class="date-time"> <draw:text-box> <text > <presentation:date-time /> </text > </draw:text-box> </draw:frame> But it is also possible with the element <draw:frame > <draw:text-box> <text > <text:date>...</text:date> </text > </draw:text-box> </draw:frame> The attribute presentation:display-date-time only affects the element with presentation:class="date-time". Therefore the current wording with mentioning the presentation class is preferable to the wording, which is used for header or footer. 20.229 presentation:display-page-number The following two structures are possible within a <style:master-page> element to get a page number. <draw:frame presentation:class="page-number"> <draw:text-box> <text > <text:page-number><number></text:page-number> </text > </draw:text-box> </draw:frame> <draw:frame> <draw:text-box> <text > <text:page-number><number></text:page-number> </text > </draw:text-box> </draw:frame> The only difference is, whether the presentation:class attribute is present or not. The presentation:display-page-number attribute affects only the <draw:frame> element with attribute presentation:class="page-number." Because both <draw:frame> elements meet the current wording "drawing shape used as a page number" a clarification is needed. 20.227 presentation:footer 20.228 presentation:header For footer or header no similar conflict exists. Therefore the wording needs no change.
          Hide
          oever Jos van den Oever [X] (Inactive) added a comment -

          The current version of the proposal is clear to me. The most important change is now no longer 20.226, but the more precise wording of 20.229.

          Show
          oever Jos van den Oever [X] (Inactive) added a comment - The current version of the proposal is clear to me. The most important change is now no longer 20.226, but the more precise wording of 20.229.
          Hide
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment -

          Applied OpenDocument-v1.3-wd-05-part3-documents.odt

          Show
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment - Applied OpenDocument-v1.3-wd-05-part3-documents.odt
          Hide
          michaelst Michael Stahl [X] (Inactive) added a comment -

          Editors: in 20.232 we have "date-time" formatted as "Attribute Value" but in 20.235 the equivalent "page-number" is "Default Style" (3 times) - should be "Attribute Value" too.

          Also, wondering if a reference to 19.393 presentation:class would help.

          Show
          michaelst Michael Stahl [X] (Inactive) added a comment - Editors: in 20.232 we have "date-time" formatted as "Attribute Value" but in 20.235 the equivalent "page-number" is "Default Style" (3 times) - should be "Attribute Value" too. Also, wondering if a reference to 19.393 presentation:class would help.
          Hide
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment -

          Applied in OpenDocument-v1.3-wd16-part3-documents.odf

          Try: "Note: *Presentation class 19.393 defines presentation class values." for the cross-ref.
          *

          Show
          patrick Patrick Durusau added a comment - Applied in OpenDocument-v1.3-wd16-part3-documents.odf Try: " Note: *Presentation class 19.393 defines presentation class values." for the cross-ref. *

            People

            • Assignee:
              Unassigned
              Reporter:
              regina.henschel Regina Henschel
            • Watchers:
              4 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: