OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TCIcon indicating the project type

OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC

Uploaded image for project: 'OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC'
  1. OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC
  2. OFFICE-4146

Additions to applied OFFICE-4110 which is related to draw:handle

    Details

    • Type: Bug
    • Status: Applied
    • Priority: Major
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Affects Version/s: None
    • Fix Version/s: ODF 1.4
    • Component/s: None
    • Labels:
    • Proposal:
      Hide

      19.180 draw:handle-radius-range-maximum
      Current:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179

      New:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-polar-radius attribute 19.928.

      19.181 draw:handle-radius-range-minimum
      Current:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179

      New:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-polar-radius attribute 19.928.

      19.182 draw:handle-range-x-maximum
      Current:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179

      New:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-x attribute 19.924.

      19.183 draw:handle-range-x-minimum
      Current:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179

      New:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-x attribute 19.924.

      19.184 draw:handle-range-y-maximum
      Current:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179

      New:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-y attribute 19.925.

      19.185 draw:handle-range-y-minimum
      Current:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179

      New:
      The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-y attribute 19.925

      Show
      19.180 draw:handle-radius-range-maximum Current: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179 New: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-polar-radius attribute 19.928. 19.181 draw:handle-radius-range-minimum Current: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179 New: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-radius-range-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-polar-radius attribute 19.928. 19.182 draw:handle-range-x-maximum Current: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179 New: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-x attribute 19.924. 19.183 draw:handle-range-x-minimum Current: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179 New: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-x-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-x attribute 19.924. 19.184 draw:handle-range-y-maximum Current: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179 New: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-maximum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-y attribute 19.925. 19.185 draw:handle-range-y-minimum Current: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position attribute, except that only the first parameter is used. 19.179 New: The syntax for the value of the draw:handle-range-y-minimum attribute is the same as the draw:handle-position-y attribute 19.925
    • Resolution:
      Hide

      As proposed.

      Show
      As proposed.

      Description

      The syntax descriptions in 19.180 to 19.185 still refer to the deprecated attributes draw:handle-polar and draw:handle-position. They need to be adapted to the new attributes 19.924 to 19.929. 

      The current wording "is the same as" is questionable, because one in the comparison is a value and the other is an attribute. But that is editorial, so I keep it for now in the proposal.

      Currently for the y-position the reference is to the first parameter, but should be to the second parameter. However the syntax is the same.

      Instead referencing the corresponding attributes, we could reference the common syntax directly, similar to what is done in 19.924 to 19.929. But doing it as in my proposal makes the connection of minimum and maximum to the corresponding attributes clearer.

        Attachments

          Activity

          Ascending order - Click to sort in descending order
          Hide
          Permalink
          franciscave Francis Cave added a comment - - edited

          At the ODF TC meeting on October 23, 2023, it was agreed that cross-references to deprecated issues should not occur in the text of non-deprecrated issues, and that this is an editorial error. The changes are to be added to the Resolution field, applied to the spec and the issue then closed.

          This decision may have wider implications, which I am investigating.

          Show
          franciscave Francis Cave added a comment - - edited At the ODF TC meeting on October 23, 2023, it was agreed that cross-references to deprecated issues should not occur in the text of non-deprecrated issues, and that this is an editorial error. The changes are to be added to the Resolution field, applied to the spec and the issue then closed. This decision may have wider implications, which I am investigating.
          Hide
          Permalink
          franciscave Francis Cave added a comment -

          The changes to the text are now completed. This issue will be closed once the changes in the master document have been reviewed.

          Show
          franciscave Francis Cave added a comment - The changes to the text are now completed. This issue will be closed once the changes in the master document have been reviewed.

            People

            • Assignee:
              Unassigned
              Reporter:
              regina.henschel Regina Henschel
            • Watchers:
              2 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: